Heating

Does Turning the Heat Down at Night Save Money? Gas Furnace vs. Heat Pump

Terrence Dowd Sr. By Terrence Dowd Sr.
October 16, 2023
4 min read
An image depicting a cozy bedroom scene at night, with a dimly lit bedside lamp illuminating a thermostat set on a lower temperature

Short answer: yes, if you heat with a gas furnace. Turning the thermostat down at night and while you’re away saves money. With a heat pump it can still save, but only if you do it the right way, or the backup heat eats the savings.

Why turning the heat down saves money

Your house loses heat to the outdoors all the time, and it loses it faster the warmer it is inside. When you let the house cool off overnight, it loses less heat for those hours. In the morning the furnace makes some of that back, but it uses less gas than it would have used holding the house warm all night.

The old idea that a furnace “works harder” to warm a cool house back up, and wipes out the savings, doesn’t hold for a gas furnace. The U.S. Department of Energy puts it at as much as 10% a year on heating and cooling by setting the thermostat back 7 to 10 degrees for 8 hours a day.

What temperature to set in winter

The Department of Energy suggests about 68 degrees while you’re home and awake, and lower while you’re asleep or away. Most people are comfortable somewhere between 66 and 70 during the day. The real savings come from how far you drop it and for how long, not from one magic number.

The heat pump catch: backup heat

A heat pump heats differently from a furnace. It moves heat in from the outdoor air, and it warms a house slowly. When a heat pump is asked to raise the temperature several degrees at once, the thermostat often turns on the backup heat, electric heat strips inside the air handler, to help. Heat strips are the most expensive way to heat with electricity.

So a deep setback on a heat pump can backfire: you save a little overnight, then pay for it at 6am when the strips kick on to warm the house back up. That is why a heat pump wants a smaller setback, and a thermostat that is set up for a heat pump and brings the temperature back gradually.

Gas furnace vs heat pump: simple setback settings

Situation Gas furnace Heat pump
Overnight 7 to 10 degrees lower (68 by day, 58 to 61 at night) 2 to 4 degrees lower (68 by day, 64 to 66 at night)
Away at work all day 7 to 10 degrees lower 2 to 4 degrees lower
Coming back up Any time; the furnace recovers quickly Start early and step it up slowly so the strips stay off
Hard freeze (teens and below) Setback still fine Skip the setback; hold one steady temperature
Gone for days 55 to 60, never off 55 to 60, never off

If you have dual fuel, a heat pump with a gas furnace as backup, the backup is gas instead of heat strips, so a deeper setback costs you less. The furnace usually handles the morning warm-up.

Is it cheaper to leave the heat on all day?

For a gas furnace, no. Holding the house at full temperature while nobody is home costs more than letting it drift down and warming it back up before you get home. For a heat pump, a small drop is fine, but a big one usually isn’t worth it.

Either way, don’t turn the heat off completely in freezing weather. Keep the house at 55 degrees or higher so pipes on outside walls don’t freeze.

Let the thermostat do the remembering

Setbacks only save money if they happen every day. A programmable or smart thermostat handles the schedule for you, and a good one knows when it is running a heat pump and limits the backup heat during warm-up. If yours can’t do that, see our thermostat services, including Rheem EcoNet controls.

Other ways to keep winter bills down

  • Open the blinds on sunny south and west windows during the day, and close them at night.
  • Change the air filter. A clogged one makes any system work harder.
  • Run ceiling fans clockwise on low to push warm air down from the ceiling.
  • Seal drafts around doors and attic hatches.

Frequently Asked Questions

What temperature should I keep my house at in winter to save money?

The lowest one you’re comfortable with. Every degree lower over a long stretch saves a little. For most homes that means about 68 while you’re home and awake, and lower overnight and while you’re away.

Does turning the heat down at night save money with a heat pump?

A small setback of 2 to 4 degrees can. A big one often doesn’t, because warming the house back up can turn on the electric backup heat. In hard freezes, holding one steady temperature is usually cheaper.

Should I turn my heat off when I leave for the day?

Turn it down, not off. In freezing weather, keep the house at 55 degrees or higher to protect your pipes.

Share this article:
Terrence Dowd Sr.

Written By

Terrence Dowd Sr.

Terrence Dowd Sr. is the founder and president of Dowd Heat and Air. Since starting the company in 1995, he's spent over 30 years serving Tulsa-area families with honest, reliable HVAC service. When he's not on a job site, Terry is sharing what he's learned to help homeowners make smart decisions about their home comfort.

Learn More About Us

Keep Reading

More HVAC Tips for Tulsa Homeowners

Ready for Help?

Keep Your Home Comfortable Year-Round

Whether you need a quick repair, a full system replacement, or just want to stay on top of maintenance, the Dowd team is here to help. Give us a call or book online.

No hidden fees. No obligation. We respond within 1 hour.

Call Now (918) 437-3721 Request Service